the u s supreme court and the domestic force of international human rights law

Download Book The U S Supreme Court And The Domestic Force Of International Human Rights Law in PDF format. You can Read Online The U S Supreme Court And The Domestic Force Of International Human Rights Law here in PDF, EPUB, Mobi or Docx formats.

The U S Supreme Court And The Domestic Force Of International Human Rights Law

Author : Stephen A. Simon
ISBN : 9781498534710
Genre : Political Science
File Size : 33. 34 MB
Format : PDF, Docs
Download : 894
Read : 167

Download Now


The core idea underlying human rights is that everyone is inherently and equally worthy of respect as a person. The emergence of that idea has been one of the most significant international developments since the Second World War. But it is one thing to embrace something as an aspirational ideal and quite another to recognize it as enforceable law. The continued development of the international human rights regime brings a pressing question to the fore: What role should international human rights have as law within the American legal system? The U.S. Supreme Court and the Domestic Force of International Human Rights Law examines this question through the prism of the U.S. Supreme Court’s handling of controversies bearing most closely on it. It shows that the specific disputes the Court has addressed can be best understood by recognizing how each interconnects with an overarching debate over the proper role to be accorded international human rights law within American institutions. By approaching the subject from the justices’ standpoint, this book reveals a divide in the Court between two fundamentally different orientations toward the domestic impact of the international human rights regime.

Universal Rights And The Constitution

Author : Stephen A. Simon
ISBN : 9781438451855
Genre : Law
File Size : 52. 34 MB
Format : PDF, ePub, Docs
Download : 366
Read : 683

Download Now


Innovative examination of the tensions between universal and more uniquely American definitions of cherished rights. Are constitutional rights based exclusively in uniquely American considerations, or are they based at least in part on principles that transcend the boundaries of any particular country, such as the requirements of freedom or dignity? By viewing constitutional law through the prism of this fundamental question, Universal Rights and the Constitution exposes an overlooked difficulty with opinions rendered by the Supreme Court, namely, an inherent ambiguity about the kinds of arguments that count in constitutional interpretation, which weakens the foundations of our most cherished rights. Rejecting current debates over constitutional interpretation as flawed, Stephen A. Simon offers an innovative framework designed to provide clearer foundations for rights interpretations while preserving a meaningful but limited role for universal arguments. He reveals the vital connections among contemporary debates over such matters as the right to privacy, the constitutionality of the death penalty, and the role of foreign law in constitutional interpretation.

Invoking International Human Rights Law In Domestic Courts

Author : Richard B. Lillich
ISBN : STANFORD:36105062996561
Genre : Political Science
File Size : 36. 54 MB
Format : PDF, Docs
Download : 445
Read : 1055

Download Now


This publication describes the application of international human rights law, treaties, and cases in U.S. courts.

Comparative International Law

Author : Anthea Roberts
ISBN : 9780190697570
Genre : Law
File Size : 25. 71 MB
Format : PDF, Kindle
Download : 931
Read : 286

Download Now


By definition, international law, once agreed upon and consented to, applies to all parties equally. It is perhaps the one area of law where cross-country comparison seems inappropriate, because all parties are governed by the same rules. However, as this book explains, states sometimes adhere to similar, and at other times, adopt different interpretations of the same international norms and standards. International legal rules are not a monolithic whole, but are the basis for ongoing contestation in which states set forth competing interpretations. International norms are interpreted and redefined by national executives, legislatures, and judiciaries. These varying and evolving interpretations can, in turn, change and impact the international rules themselves. These similarities and differences make for an important, but thus far, largely unexamined object of comparison. This is the premise for this book, and for what the editors call "comparative international law." This book achieves three objectives. The first is to show that international law is not a monolith. The second is to map the cross-country similarities and differences in international legal norms in different fields of international law, as well as their application and interpretation with regards to geographic differences. The third is to make a first and preliminary attempt to explain these differences. It is organized into three broad thematic sections, exploring: conceptual matters, domestic institutions and comparative international law, and comparing approaches across issue-areas. The chapters are authored by contributors who include leading international law and comparative law scholars with diverse backgrounds, experience, and perspectives.

Globalizing Justice

Author : Donald W. Jackson
ISBN : 9781438430713
Genre : LAW
File Size : 37. 16 MB
Format : PDF, ePub
Download : 254
Read : 972

Download Now


Essays assessing the impact of globalization on law and court systems across the world.

Extraterritorial Application Of Human Rights Treaties

Author : Marko Milanovic
ISBN : 9780191504808
Genre : Law
File Size : 53. 16 MB
Format : PDF, Kindle
Download : 927
Read : 781

Download Now


Questions as to when a state owes obligations under a human rights treaty towards an individual located outside its territory are being brought more and more frequently before both international and domestic courts. Victims of aerial bombardment, inhabitants of territories under military occupation, deposed dictators, suspected terrorists detained in Guantanamo by the United States, and the family of a former KGB spy who was assassinated in London through the use of a radioactive toxin, allegedly at the orders or with the collusion of the Russian government - all of these people have claimed protection from human rights law against a state affecting their lives while acting outside its territory. These matters are extremely politically and legally sensitive, leading to much confusion, ambiguity and compromise in the existing case law. This study attempts to clear up some of this confusion, and expose its real roots. It examines the notion of state jurisdiction in human rights treaties, and places it within the framework of international law. It is not limited to an inquiry into the semantic, ordinary meaning of the jurisdiction clauses in human rights treaties, nor even to their construction into workable legal concepts and rules. Rather, the interpretation of these treaties cannot be complete without examining their object and purpose, and the various policy considerations which influence states in their behaviour, and courts in their decision-making. The book thus exposes the tension between universality and effectiveness, which is itself the cause of methodological and conceptual inconsistency in the case law. Finally, the work elaborates on the several possible models of the treaties' extraterritorial application. It offers not only a critical analysis of the existing case law, but explains the various options that are before courts and states in addressing these issues, as well as their policy implications.

National Courts And The International Rule Of Law

Author : André Nollkaemper
ISBN : 9780191652837
Genre : Law
File Size : 55. 31 MB
Format : PDF, Docs
Download : 584
Read : 1067

Download Now


This book explores the way domestic courts contribute to the maintenance of theinternational of law by providing judicial control over the exercises of public powers that may conflict with international law. The main focus of the book will be on judicial control of exercise of public powers by states. Key cases that will be reviewed in this book, and that will provide empirical material for the main propositions, include Hamdan, in which the US Supreme Court reviewed detention by the United States of suspected terrorists against the 1949 Geneva Conventions; Adalah, in which the Supreme Court of Israel held that the use of local residents by Israeli soldiers in arresting a wanted terrorist is unlawful under international law, and the Narmada case, in which the Indian Supreme Court reviewed the legality of displacement of people in connection with the building of a dam in the river Narmada under the ILO Indigenous and Tribal Populations Convention 1957 (nr 107). This book explores what it is that international law requires, expects, or aspires that domestic courts do. Against this backdrop it maps patterns of domestic practice in the actual or possible application of international law and determines what such patterns mean for the protection of the international rule of law.

Clearinghouse Review

Author :
ISBN : OSU:32437122287788
Genre : Consumer protection
File Size : 39. 32 MB
Format : PDF, ePub
Download : 438
Read : 664

Download Now



Judicial Independence And Human Rights In Latin America

Author : E. Skaar
ISBN : 9780230117693
Genre : Social Science
File Size : 32. 62 MB
Format : PDF, ePub, Mobi
Download : 292
Read : 1244

Download Now


This comparative analysis, focusing on Argentina, Chile, and Uruguay, explores the complex relationship between executive politics and judicial action, showing that judicial independence is a crucial factor in prosecution. It will engage Latin Americanists as well as all who are concerned with justice and human rights around the world.

The African Human Rights System Activist Forces And International Institutions

Author : Obiora Chinedu Okafor
ISBN : 9781139463010
Genre : Political Science
File Size : 66. 20 MB
Format : PDF, Kindle
Download : 459
Read : 1155

Download Now


This 2007 book draws from and builds upon many of the more traditional approaches to the study of international human rights institutions (IHIs), especially quasi-constructivism. The author reveals some of the ways in which many such domestic deployments of the African system have been brokered or facilitated by local activist forces, such as human rights NGOs, labour unions, women's groups, independent journalists, dissident politicians, and activist judges. In the end, the book exposes and reflects upon the inherent inability of the dominant compliance-focused model to adequately capture the range of other ways - apart from via state compliance - in which the domestic invocation of IHIs like the African system can contribute - albeit to a modest extent - to the pro-human rights alterations that can sometimes occur in the self-understandings, conceptions of interest or senses of appropriateness held within key domestic institutions within states.

Top Download:

Best Books